BATAVIA PLAYERS, INC. • MAIN ST. 56 THEATER
  • About Us
    • Plan Your Visit
    • Youth Theatre
    • Volunteer
    • Donate
  • Auditions
    • Auditions - Annie & Orphans
    • Auditions - Annie
  • 2026 Season
    • The Miracle Worker
    • The Mystery of Edwin Drood
    • Annie
    • A Christmas Carol
    • Subscriptions
    • Hometown Christmas 2026
  • 2027 Season
    • Season Sponsorships
    • Murder at First Sight
  • Become a Member
  • Merchandise

The Mystery of Edwin Drood

Performances: November 6-8
Who killed Edwin Drood? In Rupert Holmes’ interactive musical mystery, the audience casts the deciding votes—and helps determine how the story ends.
Poster for The Mystery of Edwin Drood, a musical by Rupert Holmes, presented by Batavia Players, November 6-8, 2026.
Production Team
Director & Choreographer - Sophie Houseman
Rehearsal & Pit Pianist - John Novak
Pit Coordinator - Kathy White
Lighting Designer - Jimmy Ehrig Howes-Garofalo
Costume Designer - Spencer Efing-VanValkenburg
Sound Designer - TBD
Props Designer - Samantha Ploetz
Set Build - Anthony Haitz & Charley Scheffler
​Set Painter - Carol Wolfe & Cast
Directed and choreographed by Sophie Houseman

Book, music, and lyrics by Rupert Holmes
Based on the unfinished novel by Charles Dickens​
​
November 6th at 7:30pm
November 7th at 7:30pm
November 8th at 2:00pm


A theatrical company takes the stage to perform Charles Dickens’ final mystery but there is one considerable problem: Dickens died before completing the story.

When Edwin Drood disappears, suspicion falls across a collection of eccentric characters, each with secrets, motives, and something to hide. Because the original novel has no official conclusion, this inventive musical gives the audience the power to finish it.

Throughout the performance, watch the clues, consider the suspects, and prepare to cast your vote. Audience choices help determine the identity of the murderer and shape the final outcome of the evening.

Featuring memorable music, sharp comedy, bold choreography, suspense, and direct audience participation, The Mystery of Edwin Drood is part musical, part murder mystery, and part live theatrical game.

No two performances have to end the same way. Return on another night, cast a different vote, and you may see an entirely different solution.

Come prepared to laugh, investigate, and decide the fate of the characters because this time, the ending is up to you.

​Running time: Approximately 120 minutes

Picture
Cast
Chairman / Mayor Sapsea - Steve Coburn
John Jasper - Charley Scheffler
Edwin Drood - Sarah Hill
Rosa Bud - Cate Ciccarelli
Rev. Crisparkle - Puck Gross
Neville Landless - Deacon Smith
Helena Landless - Erin Stamp
Princess Puffer - Christy Saeva
Durdles / Satyr - Seth Coburn
Deputy / Beatrice / Flo / Shade of Jasper / Succuba / Maid / Throttle - Lilah Mordell
Bazzard / Waiter - James Barcomb
Wendy / Shade of Drood / Horace / Succuba / Maid - ​Samantha Ploetz
Get Tickets for The Mystery of Edwin Drood
Explore the Full 2026 Season

Stay Connected with Batavia Players

    Receive news about upcoming performances, ticket sales, auditions, volunteer opportunities, youth theatre programs, memberships, and special events at Main St. 56 Theater.​

Subscribe to Newsletter

Proud Member of:
Picture
  • About Us
    • Plan Your Visit
    • Youth Theatre
    • Volunteer
    • Donate
  • Auditions
    • Auditions - Annie & Orphans
    • Auditions - Annie
  • 2026 Season
    • The Miracle Worker
    • The Mystery of Edwin Drood
    • Annie
    • A Christmas Carol
    • Subscriptions
    • Hometown Christmas 2026
  • 2027 Season
    • Season Sponsorships
    • Murder at First Sight
  • Become a Member
  • Merchandise