Sunday Performance
​To ensure everyone can participate comfortably, the Sunday performance will be fully contained within the theatre and will not include the walk-around element. This performance is ideal for patrons who prefer limited walking, need a more accessible experience, or simply want to enjoy the mystery from one central location.

You’ll still piece together motives, track alibis, and follow the twists of the story before helping determine whodunit, fully immersed in the world of the show, just in a more stationary format.

Happily Never After:
A Main St. 56 Murder Mystery

---

Written and Directed by Sophie Houseman
May 8 at 6pm
May 9 at 4pm
May 10 at 1pm

Maniacal, messed up, and murderously entertaining, Happily Never After is a delightfully dark mystery that brings together the villain-adjacent relatives of the fairytale world’s most infamous baddies at their annual gala.

What begins as a twisted celebration quickly takes a shocking turn and suddenly every guest is a suspect. Secrets unravel, alliances crumble, and no one is quite as innocent as they seem.
This immersive theatrical experience invites audiences to step into the story and become the detective in this highly anticipated Main St. 56 murder mystery.

How It Works
Audience members will walk around the local area, speaking directly with suspects, uncovering secrets, and gathering clues as the mystery unfolds. This year’s experience has been thoughtfully designed with partner locations very close to the theatre, keeping the walk manageable, accessible, and easy to enjoy.

You’ll piece together motives, track alibis, and follow the twists of the story before helping determine whodunit, all while fully immersed in the world of the show.
​
Designed to be family-friendly, Happily Never After is perfect for adults and early teens, making it a fun and engaging experience for families who want to solve the mystery together.
​
Wickedly fun, cleverly crafted, and full of surprises, Happily Never After promises an evening of laughter, intrigue, and theatrical mischief, no glass slippers required.

Tickets >

See the Entire 2026 Season >